In the eternal dessert debate between cupcakes and brownies, America has spoken decisively: brownies dominate with 53% of the vote compared to cupcakes’ 28%, while 12% can’t choose and 6% have no opinion. This 25-point gap reveals striking patterns about happiness, lifestyle choices, and even work habits that suggest our dessert preferences might reveal more about our emotional states than our taste buds.
Demographically, the divide cuts across clear lines (excluding those who answered ‘no opinion’ and ‘neither of them’). Young adults 18-29 split nearly evenly (51% cupcakes, 49% brownies), but brownie preference strengthens with age, reaching 67% among seniors 65+. Women favor cupcakes more than men (43% vs 33%), while men overwhelmingly choose brownies at 67%. The Northeast and Midwest show strongest cupcake support (42% and 46% respectively), while the South and West lean heavily brownie (66% and 68%). Most remarkably, remote workers are brownie devotees at 92%, while in-person workers show more balance at 45% cupcakes to 55% brownies.
The happiness connection proves particularly intriguing. Brownie lovers report significantly less happiness recently—21% say they’ve felt “somewhat less” happy than usual over the past week, compared to just 12% of cupcake fans. Meanwhile, cupcake enthusiasts are nearly twice as likely to report feeling “much less” happy (27% vs 6%), creating a complex emotional picture. This suggests cupcake lovers experience more extreme emotional swings while brownie fans maintain steadier but potentially lower baseline moods.
Lifestyle differences emerge clearly across multiple measures. Cupcake people wake up earlier—39% rise between 2am-6am versus 43% of brownie lovers—suggesting they’re morning people tackling dawn workouts or early commutes. They’re also slightly more prone to snacking between meals (57% vs 53%) and marginally more likely to admit digital device addiction (19% definitely addicted vs 13% for brownie fans).
The international cuisine preferences reveal cultural leanings: cupcake lovers gravitate toward Italian food at 45% compared to brownies’ 37%, while brownie enthusiasts show stronger preference for Mexican cuisine (33% vs 28%). This Italian-Mexican divide might reflect broader patterns about comfort food choices—pasta versus tacos mapping onto frosting versus fudge.
These patterns paint cupcake lovers as early-rising, emotionally volatile, digitally connected snackers with a taste for Italian cuisine and potential mood extremes. Brownie fans emerge as later-rising, emotionally steadier remote workers who prefer heartier foods and maintain more consistent (if slightly dampened) happiness levels. In the great dessert divide, we’re not just choosing between frosting and fudge—we’re revealing fundamental differences in how we approach work, happiness, and daily life.
Love taking polls? Sign up to participate in the Poll of the Day here.
This article’s data comes solely from CivicScience’s database, which contains nearly 700,000 poll questions and 5 billion consumer insights.