When it comes to pierogies, Americans who have tried them and have a preference are split into clear camps: 41% declare them “amazing,” 38% find them just “okay,” while 21% openly dislike these Polish dumplings. But this simple preference reveals surprising patterns about age, culinary adventure, and lifestyle choices that extend far beyond the plate.
Pierogi appreciation increases dramatically with age. Young adults (18-29) are evenly split with 41% loving them and 29% disliking them, but older Americans show much stronger enthusiasm. Those 65+ lead in pierogi love at 48%, while their dislike drops to just 8%—a massive 40-point gap. This suggests pierogies may represent comfort food nostalgia or traditional European-American culinary heritage that resonates more with older generations. Women, meanwhile, slightly outpace men in pierogi appreciation at 43% versus 39%, though both genders show identical 21% dislike rates.
Culinary Adventurousness: Pierogi lovers are significantly more likely to be culinary explorers, with 42% saying they “don’t typically keep up with new things because they already know what they like”—compared to just 22% of pierogi haters. This counterintuitive finding suggests that appreciating traditional comfort foods like pierogies actually correlates with food conservatism rather than adventurous eating.
Home Cooking Connection: The biggest revelation is the cooking correlation. Pierogi enthusiasts are passionate home cooks, with 42% saying they “love to cook” compared to just 18% of pierogi haters—a striking 24-point gap. Meanwhile, pierogi skeptics are more likely to dislike cooking entirely at 21% versus 14% of lovers.
Snacking Habits: Pierogi fans prefer evening snacking at 39%, while those who dislike them are more evenly distributed throughout the day. This suggests pierogi lovers may appreciate heartier, meal-like snacks that align with traditional dinner timing.
Convenience Store Culture: Those who aren’t fans of pierogies are the most frequent convenience store shoppers, with 32% visiting weekly compared to 28% of lovers. This 4-point difference, while modest, hints that pierogi appreciation may correlate with more traditional grocery shopping and home meal preparation.
The pierogi divide isn’t just about dumplings—it’s a window into America’s relationship with traditional comfort foods, home cooking, and culinary heritage. Those who love pierogies represent a segment that values cooking, tradition, and hearty comfort foods, while the skeptics may gravitate toward more modern, convenient food options. In a world of fusion cuisine and food trends, pierogi preference reveals whether you’re team tradition or team innovation.
Love taking polls? Sign up to participate in the Poll of the Day here.
This article’s data comes solely from CivicScience’s database, which contains nearly 700,000 poll questions and 5 billion consumer insights.