Beyond Apple Pie: The Diverse Demographics of America’s Dessert Preferences

In a survey conducted by CivicScience, apple pie emerged as the favorite among 3,089 U.S. respondents, capturing 22% of the vote. This classic dessert edged out berry and pumpkin pies, each favored by 13% of participants. The survey offers a detailed look at the demographics behind these preferences.

Gender differences are notable. Apple pie fans are predominantly male, with 56% identifying as such, while pumpkin pie enthusiasts are 57% female. This gender divide extends to other pies, with ice cream pie also attracting a male majority at 57%, whereas key lime pie sees a female preference at 54%.

Education levels reveal further distinctions. A quarter of apple pie lovers hold a bachelor’s degree, aligning closely with key lime pie fans. In contrast, 28% of those who prefer “other” pies have some college education but no degree. Ice cream pie fans stand out with 31% having only a high school diploma or GED.

Age demographics show apple pie’s appeal to older generations, with 22% of its fans aged 65 or older. This trend is mirrored by berry and key lime pies. Conversely, ice cream pie attracts a younger crowd, with 22% aged 18-24.

Income levels add another layer of complexity. Apple pie fans are diverse, with 24% earning less than $30,000 annually. Ice cream pie fans are slightly more concentrated in this income bracket at 26%. Meanwhile, key lime pie enthusiasts are more affluent, with 20% earning between $100,000 and $149,999.

Parental status also varies. Peach pie fans are most likely to be parents, with 41% identifying as such. In contrast, 48% of those who dislike pie are neither parents nor grandparents, highlighting a potential generational gap in pie preferences.

Urbanicity paints a picture of where these pie lovers reside. Apple pie fans, accounting for 44% of respondents, predominantly live in the suburbs. Berry pie fans are even more suburban, at 49%. Meanwhile, pumpkin pie enthusiasts are more rural, with 33% living in such areas.

These findings offer a nuanced view of pie preferences across the United States, revealing how factors like gender, education, and income influence dessert choices. The data suggests that while apple pie remains a beloved classic, other pies have carved out distinct niches among different demographic groups.

Keep answering questions.

This article’s data comes solely from CivicScience’s database, which contains nearly 700,000 poll questions and 5 billion consumer insights. Our AI content creation tool, DataScribe, supported the article.

Want the latest insights?

CivicScience provides a foundational source of truth to drive positive impact for humanity, brands, and media.

Sign up today to get our latest insights sent straight to your inbox each week.